logoalt Hacker News

WalterBrighttoday at 2:36 AM2 repliesview on HN

I'm pretty sure mammals and birds are conscious. Insects, probably not.


Replies

falcor84today at 2:58 AM

Why? Are you arguing that insects are purely automatons? I personally don't have a strong view on insects, but my intuition is that there are different degrees of consciousness, and feel natural to attribute some consciousness to insects, and even individual amoebas, and maybe even (as in Chalmers's famous example) to thermostats.

I would draw a separate line around sapience, and particularly the capacity for suffering, maybe indeed attributing it to mammals and birds but not insects, but consciousness seems more widespread to me.

show 1 reply
mattclarkdotnettoday at 3:00 AM

If you were to force the choice I might agree. But I’d prefer to think there’s likely a sliding scale in operation here. Even humans aren’t conscious all the time, or equally conscious at all times. It will be an amazing day when we figure this out.