logoalt Hacker News

80386 Protection

52 pointsby nand2mariolast Tuesday at 3:56 PM9 commentsview on HN

Comments

dsigntoday at 8:45 AM

I've wondered for a long time if we would have been able to make do without protected mode (or hardware protection in general) if user code was verified/compiled at load, e.g. the way the JVM or .NET do it...Could the shift on transistor budget have been used to offset any performance losses?

show 1 reply
4j452j45njtoday at 8:30 AM

ah, PDE/PTE A/D writes... what a source of variety over the decades!

some chips set them step by step, as shown in the article

others only set them at them very end, together

and then there are chips which follow the read-modify-write op with another read, to check if the RMW succeeded... which promptly causes them to hang hard when the page tables live in read-only memory i.e. ROM... fun fun fun!

as for segmentation fun... think about CS always being writeable in real mode... even though the access rights only have a R but no W bit for it...

jejgkgkldltoday at 6:45 AM

Article states that win 3.0 used 32-bit flat addressing mode, but when win 95 launched ms said win 3.0 didn’t (in 386 mode).

show 2 replies
icanhasjonastoday at 6:06 AM

Made me think of the old Desqview