logoalt Hacker News

amiga386yesterday at 6:08 PM3 repliesview on HN

Do you need Google to compel the author to start a business relationship with them, which they can cut off at any time?

Or would you be OK knowing that Thunderbird you downloaded from https://thunderbird.net/ is signed by the thunderbird.net certificate owner?


Replies

jyoung8607yesterday at 6:25 PM

Typo squatting is a thing, and so are Unicode homographs.

The permissions approach isn't bad. I may trust Thunderbird for some things, but permission to read SMS and notifications is permission to bypass SMS 2FA for every other account using that phone number. It deserves a special gate that's very hard for a scammer to pass. The exact nature of the gate can be reasonably debated.

verdvermyesterday at 6:14 PM

Something like Thunderbird might be an exception, but also domain confusion exists, so in the general case, most likely not because most users are susceptible to this.

joshuamortonyesterday at 7:11 PM

should I be confident that thunderbird.net is the real one, or could it be hosted at thunderbird.org, thunderbird.com, or thunderbird.mozilla.org?