logoalt Hacker News

thephybertoday at 3:19 AM1 replyview on HN

All of the coverage of this is about the negotiation points of Anthropic vs Pentagon.

Anthropic doesn’t want their software used for certain purposes, so they maintain approval/denial of projects and actions. I suspect the Pentagon doesn’t want limitations AND they dislike paying for software/service which can be withheld from them if they are found to be skirting the contractual terms.

And THAT is why the Pentagon is using maximum leverage (threatening Anthropic as a supply chain risk label).


Replies

gaigalastoday at 5:58 AM

> Anthropic doesn’t want their software used for certain purposes

How do you know the government asked for a specific use case?

As far as I know, the meeting was private and we don't know what they talked about. I haven't found a single official press release or verified statement that supports this.

The verified statements I found are just about the government wanting unrestricted access. That alone is not enough to imply "no guardrails". As I mentioned before, it could be just for auditing (especially in the light of current events involving distilling of the models).

I think it's an extraordinary coincidence that this happened soon after the distillation thing. And I don't know what it means if it's not a coincidence.