logoalt Hacker News

xiphias2yesterday at 2:05 PM3 repliesview on HN

,,AI has limited real world experience or grasp of the consequences.''

People in the world have limited experience about war.

We're living in a world where doing terrible things with 1000 people with photo/video documentation can get more attention then a million people dying, and the response is still not do whatever it takes so that people don't die.

And now we are at a situation where nuclear escalation has already started (New START was not extended).

It would have been the biggest and most concerning news 80 years ago, but not anymore.


Replies

arcade79yesterday at 9:03 PM

> And now we are at a situation where nuclear escalation has already started (New START was not extended).

This is a massive understatement. Russia has announced, and probably tested, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9M730_Burevestnik . This is basically Project Pluto reloaded, but now as a Russian instead of a US missile.

I remember reading about Project Pluto some 25 years ago or so. It was terrifying to read about. And now Russia has realized it.

embedding-shapeyesterday at 2:09 PM

> People in the world have limited experience about war.

Right, but realistically, how many people today would carelessly chose "Nuke em" today? I know history knowledge isn't at its all time high directly, and most of the population is, well, not great at reasoning, but I still think most people would try to do their best to avoid firing nukes.

show 5 replies
georgemcbayyesterday at 8:56 PM

> People in the world have limited experience about war.

Most (but not all) people have empathy, which allows them to understand the harm of their actions even without direct experience.

I don't think I will ever trust that any AI has empathy even if it gives off signals that it does.

I only trust that it exists in people because of my shared experience with their biology.