logoalt Hacker News

triceratopsyesterday at 2:48 PM3 repliesview on HN

> AI has limited real world experience or grasp of the consequences [of nuclear weapons]

I don't understand this argument. Almost no human has real world experience of the consequences of nuclear weapons. AI is working from the same sources of knowledge as the rest of us - text, audio, pictures, and video.


Replies

yndoendoyesterday at 4:03 PM

AI has zero understanding of reality. It just regurgitates what it is told from training. There is no feedback loop to learn nor any consequence to the reasoned results.

Us human hallucinate, daily in fact. Example for people that have never had long hair.

1) Grow your hair long.

2) Your peripheral vision will start to be consumed by your hair.

3) Your hair will fall and sway causing your brain to think in flight / fight mode and you will turn your head to see.

4) Turning and looking causes feedback to acknowledge it was an hallucination.

5) Your brain now restricts the flight / fight mode because it was trained with continual feedback that it was just the wind blowing it or your head's juxtaposition that caused it.

Even though I told you about this and it is the first time growing your hair after, your brain still needs the real world experience to mitigate the hallucination.

AI has none of these abilities ...

jqpabc123yesterday at 2:52 PM

Almost no human has real world experience of the consequences of nuclear weapons.

Exactly!

Humans possess this amazing ability to understand and extrapolate beyond personal experience.

It's called "intelligence".

show 1 reply
black6yesterday at 2:54 PM

AI is not at all like real intelligence. Computers do not know what words mean because they do not experience the world as we do. They don't have the common sense or wisdom that people accumulate through the experience of life. Humans can understand the consequences of nuclear war. Computers can only predict the next best word in their response from a statistical map that has no connection to meatspace.

show 1 reply