logoalt Hacker News

inigyouyesterday at 11:28 PM10 repliesview on HN

Some people are calling it the "American century of humiliation"

No other country that went through a phase like this has ever recovered. Not even in a century.


Replies

davidwyesterday at 11:32 PM

I won't give in to doomerism.

Germany, Italy and Japan are all wealthy, stable democracies right now. Not without their problems and baggage, but pleasant places in a lot of ways.

show 4 replies
Dumblydorryesterday at 11:46 PM

That’s just historically inaccurate. You had massive upheavals across numerous countries throughout time, this is small in comparison to the civil war’s impact on the USA for instance. You think this is worse than half the government rebelling and revolting and killing an amount of young men that today would be equivalent to 6 million deaths? It’s bad now but your comment lacks historical evidence.

testfrequencytoday at 7:49 AM

On eastern social media a big discussion going around right now is referring to America as being on the “kill line”.

The world knows the US is close to folding in on itself.

jonplackettyesterday at 11:48 PM

China seems to have recovered pretty well.

show 1 reply
nostrademonstoday at 4:54 AM

U.S. Civil War? Roman Crisis of the 3rd Century? Russian Revolution? England's War of the Roses? China's periodic dynastic changes?

They usually don't come back with the same political organization - that's sorta the point. But plenty of civilizations come back in a form that is culturally recognizable and even dominate afterwards.

giwooktoday at 4:47 AM

I’d be interested to see some specific examples cited as it’s hard to take this comment at face value.

Pxtltoday at 4:34 AM

The Unenlightenment. Dereconstruction.

> No other country that went through a phase like this has ever recovered. Not even in a century.

Oh I can think of a couple in the '40s that bounced back after a while.

IAmGraydontoday at 3:41 AM

This is a laughably ridiculous assertion.

tsunamifurytoday at 12:25 AM

Rome was 'in decline' for 1000 years... these things are mostly feel good blather and not realistic statements on the position of nations

gbnwlyesterday at 11:56 PM

Is this a joke that’s going over my head? The country we all know the term “century of humiliation” from has recovered and is literally a superpower right now?