logoalt Hacker News

inkysigmatoday at 4:07 AM1 replyview on HN

Passkeys are an open standard? You might as well argue against SSH keys.


Replies

hedoratoday at 4:11 AM

The standard includes a hardware attestation path.

That’s the backdoor allowing the eventual takeover of your OS.

First people use passkeys, and they become standard.

Then they become required for important accounts for security.

Then the important accounts require the attestation bit.

At that point, you cannot run web browsers on open source operating systems.

This is all boring and predictable. It is exactly what they did with Android, and exactly the same organizations are pushing passkeys.

Note: If they had good intentions, the operating system would manage any attestation, and not allow websites to query for or require attestation support.

show 1 reply