logoalt Hacker News

rcarmoyesterday at 9:35 PM3 repliesview on HN

This feels misguided. MCP is still one of the best ways to execute deterministic sub-flows (i.e., stepwise processes) and secure tooling that an LLM would either lose itself while executing or should never access directly.


Replies

plufzyesterday at 9:38 PM

Im still struggling with understanding when MCP works better. I move everything to cli after a while. Can you give me more concrete examples? Because I don’t doubt you, I just don’t understand.

show 1 reply
singularity2001today at 7:49 AM

state. i'm not sure if they had that in mind but one keyword that is important here is: state. Sure CLI tools can also affect state, but in MCP service it's somewhat more natural?

x3n0ph3n3yesterday at 11:09 PM

It's the security layer that I'm most interested with MCPs. Granting full access to the CLI feels super dangerous and maybe there are options to certain commands that I want to restrict from LLM usage.