logoalt Hacker News

jimbooonoootoday at 1:52 AM2 repliesview on HN

Of course it seems fair to you, it's not your IP that's being stolen before you were able to extract all it's worth from.


Replies

onionisafruittoday at 5:23 AM

It’s not being stolen because he would have published it knowing the copyright laws. Also even with copyright laws as they are, selling unlicensed copies isn’t theft. It’s illegal but no stealing is involved.

AlotOfReadingtoday at 4:54 AM

You've completely misunderstood the social contract inherent in copyright. There's no theft in adaptation. Copyright is an intentional trade-off by society to incentivise the creation of new works for society's benefit by giving authors a temporary monopoly. Perpetual copyright would obviously maximize the incentives for authors, but harm society by precluding the creation of new works based on the original. Instead, society chooses a limited period where authors can get most of the benefit while trying to keep the period short enough that works remain relevant.

Saying it's all theft entirely misses the point.