logoalt Hacker News

Imustaskforhelpyesterday at 3:00 PM1 replyview on HN

Now that does say something about the world, doesn't it?

I think this had just made me curious so yeah haha

I mean one thing I am not understanding is why they would write an article with AI tho. They still prompted AI, might as well give us what they prompted or just write under <300 words or less. I mean its literally twitter (refuse to call it X)

Or like make a 2 minute video with screenshare just talking to the camera about it like they might've with claude perhaps.

They also have discord, They could have literally given a free contributor to help write the article from such video or concerns and credit them properly. I mean, heck I could've written the article for free for just a credit at this point where I got so invested haha.

I genuinely don't understand why you would prompt an article/text out of all things with AI. I hope I never get persuaded with this dark side lol.


Replies

roywigginsyesterday at 3:04 PM

My guesses in no particular order:

1) this style genuinely is preferred by lots of people on X/Twitter so you might as well lean into it

2) People who spend a lot of time with LLMs think this sort of writing is normal or even standard just through overexposure, a sort of pseudo social proof

2b) People who spend a lot of time with other people who use LLMs think this is how humans write (actual social proof)

3) People are insecure about their writing ability and find the non-judgmental non-human LLM editor soothing

4) people are lazy

5) people aren't lazy per se but they know writing has been so devalued that they aren't going to spend time on it that they don't need to

6) their first experience of writing was trying to hit word count requirements in grade school and that stuck

7) Visibly using LLMs is becoming a shibboleth for a social group on Twitter and LinkedIn. It's a marker that you are dogfooding the crappy AI tools you're developing and selling. Under this theory, being visibly LLM output is actually intentional: "look ma, no hands- all NanoClaw!"

show 1 reply