logoalt Hacker News

wang_liyesterday at 4:39 PM3 repliesview on HN

Last week I put "was val kilmer in heat" into the search box on my browser. The AI answer came back with "No, Val Kilmer was not in heat. Val Kilmer played Chris Shiherlis in the movie Heat but the film did not indicate that he was pregnant or in heat. His performance was nuanced and skilled and represents a high point of the film." I was not curious about whether he was pregnant.

We are not only not close to human level of intelligence, we are not even at dog, cat, or mouse levels of intelligence. We are not actually at any level of intelligence. Devices that produce text, images, or code do not demonstrate intelligence any more than a printer producing pages of beautiful art demonstrate intelligence.


Replies

DennisPyesterday at 5:23 PM

Honestly, when I read your first sentence, given the lack of a capital H, my brain initially went the same direction the AI did. Then I realized what you meant but since I already went there, I might have made a similar response as a joke. For the sake of my ego I'm forced to reject your claim that this is evidence of stupidity.

logicprogyesterday at 9:56 PM

> I was not curious about whether he was pregnant.

I interpreted the question the same way the AI did.

sosodevyesterday at 5:53 PM

The model that processes search results is tiny and dumb. You shouldn't compare it to the frontier models that are solving complex math problems.

show 1 reply