> The video game audience has decided, almost unanimously, that they don’t want generative AI in their games.
Nah, it's just a very vocal minority making lots of noise. We're slowly starting to see saner minds prevail, with steam backtracking on the ban of aigen and so on. People don't care if the end result is good. And the "but muh art" is just virtue signalling. I've used this example before, for me "art" is the fact that I can have a horse as my ruler in EU, not the fact that the horse might be generated by a diffusion model. Art is always in the eye of the beholder, or something.
On a more general note, like with the question "where are all the good open source projects", things will come. We're still in the learning phase of this new shiny toy that we got. It's only been 3 years since the tech is readily available, and maybe 2 years since people can take offline models and run with them. Give it time.
In the meantime, I see a lot of help from agentic coding in game dev. I've been following a space rouguelite thingy on itch, the developer has been pumping updates every other day, and the game is pretty much ready in ~1month. Sure, some updates broke stuff, some things didn't make much sense, but the speed with which the dev could take the feedback and pump out an update is remarkable. Small projects are doing it today. Larger projects will probably do it tomorrow.
My guess is that there's a big chance that the next "big thing" in gameplay w/ AI being somehow used will come from a smaller team / single dev type of thing, and not the big labs. Something genre-defining like minecraft or tarkov.
It's always this massive cop out.
"Things just got started. The future will be amazing".
I heard this with IoT, Wearables, Cryptocurrency, VR, now Gen AI.
Forgive me if after a while every vague gesture that "now it is for real" just becomes noise.
It's not only just signalling. I've never said anything about AI art in games before this moment, but if I become aware that a game has used it, I'm not getting that game.
Signalling means you are doing the thing only to identify yourself to others as being in the tribe. That's kind of the opposite of my personal take.