logoalt Hacker News

pinkmuffineretoday at 6:10 PM0 repliesview on HN

Thankyou for your well-moderated reading of the text, you're absolutely right that Gizmodo's article is blowing it out of proportion. The actual ask is not so absurd. My reading of the text is that all of the following are encouraged:

- The national anthem / pledge of allegiance (explicitly suggested by the text)

- Civics-related stuff -- information about voting, how laws are passed, the branches of govt, the separation of powers, etc.

- Arts that are "truly" American -- Blues, Jazz, Rock n Roll, etc. I know there will be disagreement about what counts as "American", but I think it's clear that there are some art forms that wouldn't exist without America's unique mixture of cultures.

- Things about America's history -- speeches from George Washington/Lincoln/MLK/Other significant figures, the musical Hamilton, the emancipation proclamation, the text from the statue of liberty, discussion of Japanese internment camps, the history of Hawaii/Peurto Rico/Alaska/Any relevant state, etc

I'm sure there will also be some less inclusive bits of history that are endorsed by some broadcasters. But Carr's message is not asking for that, it's just encouraging an increased focus on America. America is a melting pot, and has a great history of including downtrodden people, as well as a long history of injustice. A focus on America _doesn't_ mean we endorse the injustice. If anything, I think the injustice should be discussed, because they make the big shifts even _more_ palpable. There are people alive today that went to segregated schools. That's insane, and personally I do think that knowledge changes my behavior. I'd be very happy to be reminded about those things by public radio.

There is one line that I felt was a bit concerning, but I think it really depends on your reading of the text (emphasis mine):

> The Pledge America Campaign [encourages broadcasters to air] ... _pro-America_ content"