logoalt Hacker News

trinsic2today at 4:57 AM1 replyview on HN

So if it's an application that runs within the os that the parent enables and does not collect or send any personal info that sounds reasonable. But if has to be embedded into the OS that's going to present problems I can only imagine.


Replies

chiitoday at 5:10 AM

> But if has to be embedded into the OS

that would be fine if the embedding means all applications can leverage this functionality - like how accessibility is embedded into the OS rather than per-app.

The only problem is if this embedding requires third-party verification (which i dont believe it is), or require some sort of hardware attestation to a remote server (so you cannot modify the OS to turn it off if you wish as a non-parent).

To me, flexibility and choice is paramount. The parents have the responsibility to monitor their child, and this tool should help when the parents opt-in for it. It should not be enforced on all computer users arbitrarily without a parental opt-in first.