logoalt Hacker News

jeroenhdtoday at 10:25 AM1 replyview on HN

The syntax being referred to includes some obscure, outdated addressing formats (IPv4 addresses represented as two or three number groups in dotted notation rather than the normal 4).

However, "DNS-based reference identity [RFC9525]" seems to explicitly disallow IP-based certificates by requiring a DNS name. I can only interpret the sentence I quoted as written to say "make sure you never ever accidentally validate an IP address".


Replies

szmarczaktoday at 10:51 AM

I don't think your interpretation is right. If it were,

> Clients that incorporate DNS names and IP addresses into the same syntax

They wouldn't mention the IP addresses at all. Also, notice the word "and".