logoalt Hacker News

wolvesechoestoday at 12:31 PM1 replyview on HN

> and the worst have died away (things like goto and classical inheritance)

What's so wrong about classical inheritance, and how it died away while being well-supported in most popular programming languages of today (Python, C++, Java, C#, TS, Swift)?


Replies

Someonetoday at 1:14 PM

Inheritance has its uses, but is easily overused.

In a sense, it’s like global variables. About every complex program [1] has a few of them, so languages have to support them, but you shouldn’t have too many of them, and people tend to say “don’t use globals”.

[1] some languages such as classical Java made it technically impossible to create them, but you can effectively create one with

  class Foo {
    public static int bar;
  }
If you’re opposed to that, you’ll end up with making that field non-static and introducing a singleton instance of “Foo”, again effectively creating a global.

In some Java circles, programmers will also wrap access to that field in getters and setters, and then use annotations to generate those methods, but that doesn’t make such fields non-global.

show 1 reply