logoalt Hacker News

shinycodeyesterday at 10:13 AM2 repliesview on HN

No I don’t agree. Just because it’s « boilerplate », that does not mean it’s worthless or doesn’t carry novelty. There is « boilerplate » in building many things, house, cars etc where to add real new stuff it’s « always the same base » but you have to nail that base and there is real value in it. With craft and deep knowledge and pride. Every project is different and not everything can be made from a generic out-of-shelf product


Replies

BoredomIsFunyesterday at 2:10 PM

> Just because it’s « boilerplate », that does not mean it’s worthless

Of course it is not. It is needed, by definition.

> or doesn’t carry novelty.

Of course it does not. Why would a piece of code that simply fills a large C structure with constants be innovative?

> Every project is different and not everything can be made from a generic out-of-shelf product

Tangential to use of LLMs for boring boilerplate stuff.

jimnotgymyesterday at 11:10 AM

A house doesn't seem a good example, because it is made of physical things.

from foundations import ConcreteStrip

ConcreteStrip(x,y,z)

Doesn't work for houses

show 1 reply