logoalt Hacker News

dotancohenyesterday at 6:04 AM3 repliesview on HN

  > afraid to recognize Taiwan's independence.
Does Taiwan claim independence?

I thought that both the government in Beijing and the government in Taipei both claim that all of China is united, and that they are the legitimate government of that united entity.


Replies

YZFyesterday at 6:43 AM

You're arguing semantics. The west refuses to recognize Taiwan as the legitimate government of China and refuses to recognize it as an independent country.

Whatever they claim, the west (and most of the world) due to Chinese leverage/power refuses to recognize.

Taiwan meets all the criteria for being a state. It controls land, population, it has a military, it has a government, currency, passports etc. etc. It's a de-facto country/state.

show 1 reply
godelskiyesterday at 6:58 AM

You literally described independence.

You're confusing land with governance.

show 1 reply
XorNotyesterday at 6:33 AM

Taiwan buys military equipment and operates it's own military very much like it is independent of China and views Chinese troops in it's territory as a threat.

show 1 reply