logoalt Hacker News

xrdyesterday at 6:41 PM2 repliesview on HN

Two reasons. One, they have already filled it internally but legally have to post the job. Two, they are gathering data on market trends and what salaries people will take, which is useful if they are considering firing people and rehiring with lower salaries.

I've applied for many jobs where I was perfectly qualified and got rejection notices immediately. I applied on a Sunday and got rejected on Sunday an hour later. No human reviewed that application I made, it was auto rejected, and if that's the case, what other explanation is there than "ghost jobs."


Replies

phil21yesterday at 7:16 PM

> and if that's the case, what other explanation is there than "ghost jobs."

You didn't pass some arbitrary ruleset given to an AI or machine learning algorithm.

Companies can be very selective now, and usually implement this selectivity fairly stupidly. There also is the problem of being genuinely swamped with bullshit applicants for positions, so the false positive rate is likely quite high at the moment.

I've found it extremely difficult to sort the wheat from the chaff right now. Finding competent people is more difficult than ever, but the sheer number of applicants is at least an order of magnitude higher. Botting has made applying to jobs exceedingly low friction, so there is very little downside to someone entirely not qualified to apply to 600 jobs a day and hope they get lucky.

We have positions that have been open for months that go unfilled simply due to lack of time to sort through applicants, and the few we do have time to interview usually are obviously unqualified within the first 5 minutes of talking to them.

show 3 replies
caminanteyesterday at 8:16 PM

> Two reasons. One, they have already filled it internally but legally have to post the job.

This scenario isn't a "fake job," which are more akin to ghost/scam/non-existent openings.