logoalt Hacker News

vlovich123today at 4:48 AM2 repliesview on HN

You’re comparing a 4 year bloodbath to 10 minutes and being underimpressed? Also those weapons are several orders of magnitude less powerful than what they’re capable of today…

Battle of Carthage was also 3 years and was a siege of a city, so you know… not a lot of places for the people inside to escape. Also took about 20-50k expertly trained Roman soldiers vs a few trained guys in a plane pressing a button.

And sibling comment is right. The application of industrialization to the death process in WW2 and similar application of the idea (eg Pol Pot and Stalin) also led to death on an unprecedented scale.


Replies

jryle70today at 5:25 AM

> 4 year bloodbath

That caused endless tragedy and trauma. Perhaps the 10 mins terror was the less worse outcome of the two, mode decisive, that ended the war quicker. Who can decide? Wars aren't statistic.

show 1 reply
nwhnwhtoday at 5:15 AM

> You’re comparing a 4 year bloodbath to 10 minutes...

Poor me having hard time trying to understand how he didn't notice that by himself.