logoalt Hacker News

gzreadtoday at 12:08 PM1 replyview on HN

Right. If AI actually made you more productive, there would be more good software around, and we wouldn't have the METR study showing it makes you 20% slower.

AI delivers the feeling of productivity and the ability to make endless PoCs. For some tasks it's actually good, of course, but writing high quality software by itself isn't one.


Replies

UqWBcuFx6NV4rtoday at 1:17 PM

Ah, yes. LLM-assisted development. That thing that is not at all changing, that thing that different people aren’t doing differently, and that thing that some people aren’t definitely way better at than others. I swear that some supposedly “smart” people on this website throw their ability to think critically out the window when they want to weigh in on the AI culture war. B-but the study!

I can way with certainty that: 1. LLM-assisted development has gotten significantly, materially better in the past 12 months.

2. I would be incredibly skeptical of any study that’s been designed, executed, analysed, written about, published, snd talked about here, within that period of time.

This is the equivalent of a news headline stating with “science says…”.