logoalt Hacker News

Effort to prevent government officials from engaging in prediction markets

86 pointsby stopbulyingtoday at 8:55 PM24 commentsview on HN

Comments

romaaeternatoday at 9:59 PM

> A Mystery Trader Made $400,000 Betting on Maduro’s Downfall

> Prediction market trader 'Magamyman' made $553,000 on death of Iran's supreme leader

show 1 reply
staplungtoday at 9:24 PM

Unfortunately, it's not just elected officials that are problematic for prediction markets. The Secretary of War, for instance is not an elected official nor are leaders of the armed forces and there is definitely a prediction market for war. Multiply this by every powerful appointee and every career bureaucrat and see what kind of picture that paints.

show 3 replies
aurareturntoday at 9:01 PM

It makes sense to ban government officials from betting. It's hard enough to enforce insider trading. With legal betting, it's literally impossible.

Another worrying issue with betting is just how prevalent the last election was in betting markets. In elections won by thousands or even just hundreds of votes, betting markets can skew results where betters vote for someone just purely for the bet and persuade, shill for the person they bet on.

I can imagine betters placing a bet on a candidate and then launching a defamation campaign against the other.

trinsic2today at 10:13 PM

How is any of this going to get passed without enforcement of anti-trust and an end to citizen united?

show 1 reply
jpmoraltoday at 10:05 PM

Aren't there already basic laws against officials profiting from their role?

schnebbautoday at 10:05 PM

The answer is simple - you price in the chance that an insider could have an edge on you when making your prediction. It's all part of the game.

show 2 replies
stopbulyingtoday at 8:58 PM

> Following multiple public reports on the growing influence of prediction markets and their potential for corruption, Merkley and Klobuchar introduced the End Prediction Market Corruption Act — a new bill to ban the President, Vice President, Members of Congress, and other public officials from trading event contracts. The bill will ensure that federal elected officials maintain their oath of office to serve the people by preventing them from trading on information that they gained through their role.

ronsortoday at 9:30 PM

If we can't ban them from trading stocks, good luck with this.

show 2 replies
tokaitoday at 9:42 PM

It wouldn't be a problem if the law was actually applied to prediction markets. If crime is de facto already legal, more laws seems like the least of ones worries.

sapphirebreezetoday at 9:50 PM

[dead]

Steinmarktoday at 9:56 PM

[flagged]

show 3 replies
themafiatoday at 9:07 PM

> you have the perfect recipe to undermine the public’s belief that government officials are working for the public good

The public already does not believe this. Less than 25% approve of your work.

> This legislation strengthens the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s ability to go after bad actors

And this is designed to "increase trust?"