logoalt Hacker News

godelskitoday at 2:46 AM0 repliesview on HN

I'd argue it's so vague it's already nonsensical. Can we not declare Google (search) AGI? It sure does a hell of a lot of stuff better than any human I now. Same with the calculator in my desk drawer. Even by broom does a far better job sweeping than I do. My hands just aren't made for sweeping.

But to extend your point, I think we really need to be explicit about the assumptions being made. Everyone loves to say intelligence is easy to define but if it were then we'd have a definition. But if "you" figure it out and it's so simple then "we" are all too dumb and it needs better explaining for our poor simple minds. Or there's a lot of details that make it hard to pin down and that's why there's not a definition of it yet. Kinda like how there's no formal definition of life