logoalt Hacker News

edanmtoday at 6:44 AM1 replyview on HN

I should clarify — I disagree with disallowing any comments that used LLMs in the writing. I think comments should be judged on their quality, not on how they were written.

I might agree (don't know) with the idea of limiting new accounts more heavily.


Replies

i_think_sotoday at 8:31 AM

> I disagree with disallowing any comments that used LLMs in the writing.

I think the point here is that the community doesn't want to read AI slop, not that using an LLM to clean up your writing contains some inherent evil that prevents quality.

I don't want to accuse you of strawmanning the argument, but honestly, where did you ever see someone advocating the latter?