logoalt Hacker News

Peritracttoday at 9:41 AM2 repliesview on HN

"Explain how to solve" and "write like X" are crucially different tasks. One of them is about going through the steps of a process, and the other is about mimicking the result of a process.


Replies

z2today at 10:00 AM

Neural networks most certainly go through a process to transform input into output (even to mimic the results of another process) but it's a very different one from human neutral networks. But I think this is the crucial point of the debate, essentially unchanged from Searle's "Chinese Room" argument from decades ago.

The person in that room, looking up a dictionary with Chinese phrases and patterns, certainly follows a process, but it's easy to dismiss the notion that the person understands Chinese. But the question is if you zoom out, is the room itself intelligent because it is following a process, even if it's just a bunch of pattern recognition?

simianwordstoday at 9:44 AM

but llm can do both. so what's the point?

can you give a specific example of what an llm can't do? be specific so we can test it.

show 1 reply