logoalt Hacker News

t1234stoday at 5:56 PM4 repliesview on HN

Having driven in the UK and coming back to the US I miss all of the roundabouts. Any reason (aside from contractor profits) towns use 4-way traffic light systems vs a roundabout and some yield signs?


Replies

boctoday at 6:07 PM

Traffic lights can be tuned to create "green waves" that allows for efficient flow of traffic along arteries through a city. You can adjust the timing throughout the day to help alleviate congestion. In rural areas, heavy machinery/commercial vehicles may need to make a very wide turn through the intersection. Traffic circles are fine for a lot of applications but they aren't strictly better than lights in all circumstances.

show 1 reply
wffurrtoday at 8:05 PM

Come to Massachusetts, we have a lot of roundabouts and even a few old style two lane rotaries.

snarf21today at 7:54 PM

Space/land; you have to displace and buy the four corner properties (at least) to put one in.

0x3ftoday at 6:02 PM

Having driven in both, Americans don't take naturally to roundabouts and it would be difficult to teach all the existing drivers about them. Same in the UK when they add new rules: most drivers remain completely unaware of them.