logoalt Hacker News

ggm-at-algebrasyesterday at 9:58 PM3 repliesview on HN

It would seem passing strange that Gentry Lee came up with all the awful bits and the consulting oversight didn't.


Replies

BeetleByesterday at 10:02 PM

I've read almost all of Arthur C. Clarke's novels. The Rama sequels are nothing like his work. It's easy to believe that he barely contributed.

show 1 reply
rbanffyyesterday at 10:05 PM

I always felt that Gentry Lee kidnapped Clarke and forced him to be his co-author.

Clarke was so much of a better writer than the [2010|Rama] sequels indicate. He would not be able to screw it up so thoroughly without extensive "help".

Clarke also made some good partnerships - Richter 10 is a very good book. Sadly, the partner died and never worked with Clarke again. Gentry Lee would be my main suspect.

Sharlintoday at 1:17 AM

The terrible bits were all stuff that Clarke never wrote in any of his solo novels.