logoalt Hacker News

pmarrecktoday at 10:40 AM5 repliesview on HN

Yep, that’s why my forks of all their libraries with bugs fixed such as https://github.com/pmarreck/zigimg/commit/52c4b9a557d38fe1e1... will never ever go back to upstream, just because an LLM did it. Lame, but oh well- their loss. Also, this is dumb because anyone who wants fixes like this will have to find a fork like mine with them, which is an increased maintenance burden.


Replies

8organicbitstoday at 11:21 AM

The commit you listed was merged upstream.

https://github.com/zigimg/zigimg/pull/313

show 1 reply
il-btoday at 1:30 PM

> Also, this is dumb because anyone who wants fixes like this will have to find a fork like mine with them

Or a human will provide the fix?

lpcvoidtoday at 10:47 AM

Hugely unpopular opinion on HN, but I'd rather use code that is flawed while written by a human, versus code that has been generated by a LLM, even if it fixes bugs.

I'd gladly take a bug report, sure, but then I'd fix the issues myself. I'd never allow LLM code to be merged.

show 3 replies
orftoday at 11:21 AM

just like... don't tell them a LLM did it?

show 1 reply
voidUpdatetoday at 12:01 PM

If you know there's a bug, why not just properly fix it and get it merged, instead of outsourcing that fix?

show 1 reply