logoalt Hacker News

Why Do They Want to Get Rid of Software Engineers?

10 pointsby abnercoimbretoday at 5:22 PM7 commentsview on HN

Comments

Snoozletoday at 6:14 PM

Why does this entire article read like chatgpt? Kind of ironic considering the content.

Big llm smells: 'Not "AI helps you autocomplete a function." Not "AI explains a stack trace." I mean the full-on narrative:'

'Sure, it's a weird language. It looks archaic. Sometimes it's hostile. Sometimes it's beautiful.

But still—if you know what you're doing—you can sit down with a keyboard and turn words into:

a product a workflow an automated business process a system that makes money while you sleep a tool that saves a team thousands of hours That's real power. It's leverage.'

'Not because we're lazy. Not because we're gatekeeping. Because building real systems is hard, and the number of people who can reliably do it is limited.'

Sometimes I think we get too caught up on what chatgpt will do to the economy, software, and businesses, and forget the most insidious aspect of this type of technology - we will no longer know how to write and all human text communication will confirm to a specific pattern.

show 4 replies
ekjhgkejhgktoday at 6:13 PM

Software engineers are laborers. If you're a capital owner, a laborer is something that weights down your returns.

It's not rocket science.

show 4 replies
rglovertoday at 5:43 PM

Jealousy definitely. They can't do the thing that they depend on for money and AI gives them some feeling of power/an upper-hand. That's why the AI art types immediately started bashing traditional artists as "paint pigs."

show 2 replies
Cheyanatoday at 5:35 PM

Money.

fithisuxtoday at 5:47 PM

They want to replace software engineers because they want exclusive power and because they are not team players.

Narcissism

colesantiagotoday at 5:48 PM

> Part of this is jealousy (yes, I said it)

This feels like cope here.

They want to get rid of SWE because they are highly paid (in the US especially) and they want them for cheap (e.g. Bangalore, London)

AI just makes it a no brainer.

Also I don't think there is anything wrong with everyone being a software engineer, more accessibility to the SWE field for all is great.

Current SWE's will just need to now adapt quicker to remain relevant, and those that can't will just then leave the field.

Perhaps those that don't adapt were probably not good engineers anyway.

show 1 reply