logoalt Hacker News

kibayesterday at 11:26 PM5 repliesview on HN

It doesn't really help the United States create good law. You could argue that it worsen the quality of laws by forcing kludges to be built on top of kludges.

A sortition panel collecting random people from all walks of life to give feedback on law would probably improve the quality of law more than any amount of procedure and paperwork ever will.

We mistaken paperwork with deliberation and quality control.


Replies

kennywinkeryesterday at 11:51 PM

I’d go further. To bypass the deadlocked congress, obama used executive orders in new and expansive ways. That ratcheted things up. Now trump is using executive orders even MORE expansively, to do things that are patently undemocratic and unconstitutional (federalizing who can vote, ilegal tariffs). The kludges and hacks are causing a crumbling of democracy, not just mediocre law.

show 5 replies
laughing_mantoday at 1:17 AM

The argument isn't that it helps the US create good law. It's that it keeps the US from creating too many bad laws.

bhktoday at 12:04 AM

"The more laws, the less justice." -- Cicero

rybosworldtoday at 12:05 AM

Government needs to be more Agile.

show 1 reply