logoalt Hacker News

bsdertoday at 2:33 AM1 replyview on HN

IIRC, the issue was never how often the DVD-R/W could be rewritten.

The issue was the fact that everybody assumed that the DVD-R/W discs had roughly the same lifetime as actual DVDs and that turned out to be woefully incorrect.


Replies

tjofftoday at 6:59 AM

People did? I thought that was common knowledge, as it also was for CDs. Not only that, compatibility with players were much worse.

Though there were times were RW discs cost as much as normal ones, and some friends of mine defaulted to buying RW even for stuff that was write once. I didn't get that, but for them the ability to, maybe, reuse the disc outweighed any reliability issues.