logoalt Hacker News

DoctorOetkertoday at 4:30 PM6 repliesview on HN

the bombing of the girls school should never have happened and is inexcusable, but otherwise increasing the future safety by annihilating the military structure of an aspiring nuclear power for say $50B / 250M inhabitants = $200 per person, sounds like a steal

if only this would have been done before and thus instead of a genocide in Gaza!


Replies

tredre3today at 5:16 PM

> but otherwise increasing the future safety by annihilating the military structure of an aspiring nuclear power for say

The problem is that there's always a very convenient aspiring nuclear power to hit. In hindsight they rarely never were a real threats (Iraq, Cuba). And what became real threats have historically been downplayed by the american government (North Korea).

show 1 reply
csb6today at 6:10 PM

Attacking Iran has made the entire region less safe and so far there is no evidence Iran has been deterred. They continue to successfully hit targets with missiles and drones, and they have expanded operations to successfully close the Strait of Hormuz. Seems like it would have been a lot cheaper to not attack Iran and instead to rein in Israel, an existing nuclear power that is the primary destabilizing force in the Middle East.

fooblastertoday at 4:40 PM

This thing is far from over. Iran will indefinitely be able to block the straight. The us will be stuck in this defensive position for months, until it pulls out and effectively loses the war.

It's clear we are going to lose, because we cannot topple the regime without putting troops on the ground, which we will never do. Setting that as a war aim doomed this whole effort from the start.

show 1 reply
lm28469today at 6:25 PM

The US had a joint nuclear program with Iran for decades... After the revolution they didn't even pursue nuclear weapons until they understood it was the only thing you can get to protect yourself from Israel and American bullying.

> before and thus instead of a genocide in Gaza!

Lmao yeah OK buddy, your dollars are financing both, and many more, atrocities

testing22321today at 6:33 PM

Should America do this to every aspiring nuclear nation? All the time?

show 1 reply