logoalt Hacker News

dheerayesterday at 7:55 PM3 repliesview on HN

The one thing I hate about monorepos is nothing ever gets versioned, packaged, and shipped.

Polyrepos are workable, the way to do it is to actually version, ship, and document every subcomponent. When I mean ship, I really mean ship, as in a .deb package or python wheel with a version number, not a commit hash. AI can work with this as well, as long as it has access to the docs (which can also be AI-generated).


Replies

giorgiozyesterday at 8:06 PM

The monorepo make it easier to ship the overall product but harder to ship parts of it. I've used a monorepo for the past 13 years and I got all shared packages with version 0.0.0 and I still haven't figured out a simple way to share just some parts of it like a CLI. Does anyone have a monorepo and publishes NPM packages with source code of only that folder? Sub-gits required to pull in multiple places...

dezgegyesterday at 9:03 PM

The best thing about monorepos is nothing ever gets versioned and packaged.

That means, a subcomponent can just make a needed change in the supercomponent as well, and test and the ship the subcomponent without excess ceremonies and releases.

fixxation92yesterday at 8:53 PM

I've got about ~15 repos for a project and I just start Claude Code in the parent directory of all of them, so it has clear visibility everything and cross-reference whatever it needs.... super handy.