logoalt Hacker News

econtoday at 2:00 PM4 repliesview on HN

Education is a weird field with perhaps a few thousand years of very good unimplemented ideas.

Imagine training an llm by putting it in a room with other untrained LLMs? All that knowledge is sure to rubb of!


Replies

ACCount37today at 2:25 PM

A big part of the problem education systems are solving is not "how do we get knowledge to children", but "how do we get masses of children to learn without coercion of the ugliest kind".

Some children are innately motivated to learn. Some are motivated so strongly you could give them a smartphone and watch them learn all they need to learn in life. But those children aren't the norm - they're the freaky 1 in 1000 outliers. And education has to work with everyone.

Thus, peer pressure. That's what putting a whole bunch of students in the same room accomplishes.

show 2 replies
ameliustoday at 3:28 PM

LLMs have only a very small working memory and they don't have a memory beyond the current session.

Frickentoday at 3:41 PM

What would you recommend I read if I wanted to learn more about a few thousand years of very good unimplemented ideas?

wakamoleguytoday at 2:34 PM

I mean, that LLM idea _sounds_ ridiculous, but similar ideas have worked really well in machine learning for games like Chess and AI.

show 1 reply