logoalt Hacker News

Confiksyesterday at 7:47 PM3 repliesview on HN

This is just a Nextcloud rebrand with a confusing domain name. It claims "Core is [100%] Open Source" but no source code is provided beyond what's already available in the upstream projects, and it's unlikely that there will be (as this happens a lot). It's a one-man project without a track record or certifications based out of a shared office space [1].

And don't get me wrong: there's nothing wrong with starting a business rebranding Nextcloud and keeping your development closed source, as long as you're honest about that, which this initiative is not.

If you're looking for a Nextcloud hoster, there's a long list of partners here [2] that have contractually obligated themselves to contribute back to Nextcloud for every user they onboard.

[1] https://blog.tomaszdunia.pl/officeeu-eng/

[2] https://nextcloud.com/partners/


Replies

F3nd0yesterday at 9:29 PM

> there's nothing wrong with starting a business rebranding Nextcloud and keeping your development closed source, as long as you're honest about that, which this initiative is not.

I thought Nextcloud was released under the AGPL, making this very much not okay by default. So either I misunderstood something or Office.eu got a permission to make non-free modifications? (Going by what you said; I have not dived into this.)

show 1 reply
user2722yesterday at 8:35 PM

Agreed. But please, someone change [2] to have a freakin' direct link to the Nextcloud product/service offered by the linked website.

surgical_fireyesterday at 9:41 PM

Er... It is not hidden?

"About Office.eu

Office.eu is a 100% European all-in-one Office Suite collaboration platform. The software is partly built on Nextcloud, the leading European open source platform."

This is literally on the linked page. They are upfront about it.