logoalt Hacker News

nickfftoday at 12:54 AM8 repliesview on HN

The problem with reporting often is that the reports must each be audited (which is time-intensive and expensive), and any errors subject the companies to class-action lawsuits (which only ever benefit the lawyers, but that is a separate matter).

I would also prefer more frequent reports, but only if they were less burdensome and risky.


Replies

hatsixtoday at 1:04 AM

The reports don't have to each be audited... reduce the auditing to twice a year, increase reporting to monthly... if your report requires remediation, you her bumped to quarterly audits

show 1 reply
runakotoday at 12:57 AM

Longer periods between audited (aka "accurate") results will lead to compounding errors. Fewer people at the company will have a clear idea of how the company is doing. Audits are like CI for finances.

show 1 reply
balderdashtoday at 1:40 AM

In the us, quarterly financials are not audited, only annual financials

throw0101ctoday at 1:03 AM

Perhaps the auditing needs to be done on the workflow process and once the automated code is in place there needs to be a traceable chain of modifications to it that need to be justified.

The "audit" certifies a certain hash of a repo that produces known-good results, and if you use a different commit in that repo you have explain in an SEC filing why you modified things.

Basically reproducible builds for financial results:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reproducible_builds

show 1 reply
DesaiAshutoday at 1:19 AM

You could report every month and audit every 6 months

irjustintoday at 1:17 AM

I'm generally with the report often camp. It forces automation all the way down even the auditing.

ezfetoday at 2:15 AM

Wouldn't the auditing be proportionally easier with less data in each report?

otterleytoday at 1:26 AM

The reason for strong auditing and personal attestation is because left to their own devices, some companies will produce bullshit and hoodwink investors. Blame Enron.

https://www.britannica.com/topic/Sarbanes-Oxley-Act

Like the building and electrical code, these regulations were written in blood.

show 1 reply