logoalt Hacker News

fourseventytoday at 2:57 AM6 repliesview on HN

That doesn't make any sense because the revenue is already booked for the sale which has nothing to do with when the delivery truck actually arrives.


Replies

dragonwritertoday at 4:45 AM

If it is cash based accounting, revenue and expenses are booked when the money changes hands.

If it is accrual-based acocunting, it takes place when the event legal triggering the change of ownership of goods in the transaction takes place, which depends on the shipping terms, which could be anywhere from when it is available for the buyer’s transport agent to pick up at the seller’s facility (EXW) to when it is delivered, unloaded, and at the buyers door (DDP) or any of a variety of places in between (FOB Origin, FOB Destination, and a bunch of other potential shipping terms with their own rules on when ownership—and responsibility—transfer from seller to buyer.)

show 1 reply
jefftktoday at 1:31 PM

This is not correct. A business this big would definitely be using accrual accounting (not cash) which generally means you count the revenue when the actual ownerships transfers to the buyer. Since the truck was operated by the seller, the transfer of ownership is almost certainly counted as when the buyer receives the goods.

storyinmemotoday at 3:07 AM

It's got to be one of these:

FOB Shipping Point (or Origin): Responsibility transfers to the buyer as soon as the goods leave the seller's premises. You book it when it leaves your loading dock.

FOB Destination: The seller retains risk and costs until the goods reach the buyer’s location.

The sale doesn't happen until the asset transfer occurs. Before that any cash you get from the sale is balanced by the liability to actually produce the good or refund the money. Or more likely you don't get any cash but can't record the bill as accounts receivable. It's not receivable until the transfer point is crossed.

show 1 reply
egl2020today at 4:43 AM

Accounts receivable, revenue, and cash are related, but separate, accounting items.

carabinertoday at 5:21 AM

Ya but op's anecdote is cute and funny.

anxmantoday at 5:21 AM

Cash vs Accrual

show 1 reply