logoalt Hacker News

adrian_byesterday at 4:12 PM2 repliesview on HN

Atmospheric entry is completely relevant because some people have made the illogical claim that meteorites falling on Earth could have contributed with such complex organic substances, like the nucleobases, to the appearance of life on Earth.

The icy bodies from the outer Solar System that contain such organic substances are very easily vaporized during entry in the atmosphere of the Earth, so only a negligible fraction, if any, of the organic substances originally present in such a body would reach the surface of the Earth.


Replies

foxglacieryesterday at 9:05 PM

Wouldn't a big enough asteroid have an inner part which survives entry? You seem to be saying that it's impossible for any meteorite that might have these chemicals to not be completely vaporized which seems doubtful. Have you got a source?

show 1 reply
socoyesterday at 6:03 PM

So we get organic vapors in the atmosphere right. Shouldn't that matter?

show 1 reply