logoalt Hacker News

hatthewlast Tuesday at 10:54 PM3 repliesview on HN

A fun read!

I'm mildly thrown off by some inconsistencies. Carol says "I’ve been under-watering that spot on purpose for thirty years," and then a paragraph down Tom's thoughts say "Carol didn’t know that she under-watered the clay spot." Carol considers a drip irrigation timer the last acceptable innovation, but then the illustration points to the greenhouse as the last acceptable illustration. Several other things as well, mostly in the illustrations.

Are these real inconsistencies or am I misunderstanding? Was this story AI-assisted (in part or all)? Is this meta-commentary?


Replies

Stwernerlast Tuesday at 11:20 PM

Thanks! Yeah this was AI assisted. As an experiment I started asking Claude to explain things to me with a fiction story and it ended up being really good, so I started seeing how far I could take it.

show 1 reply
gunalxlast Tuesday at 11:11 PM

I also got a slight feeling of ai assistance as well (especially on the drawings), but the story was well written and really sucked me in all in all.