alt Hacker NewsThe Python devs didn’t want to make huge changes because they were worried Python 3 would end up taking forever like Perl 6. Instead they went to the other extreme and broke everyone’s code for trivial reasons and minimal benefit, which meant no-one wanted to upgrade.
Even the main driver for Python 3, the bytes-Unicode split, has unfortunately turned out to be sub-optimal. Python essentially bet on UTF-32 (with space-saving optimisations), while everyone else has chosen UTF-8.
Replies
Ironically Perl 5 managed to do the bytes-Unicode split with a feature gate, no giant major version change.
> Python essentially bet on UTF-32 (with space-saving optimisations), while everyone else has chosen UTF-8.
It did nothing of the sort. UTF-8 is the default source file encoding and has been the target for many APIs. It likely would have been the default for all I/O stuff if we lived in a world where Windows had functioning Unicode in the terminal the whole time and didn't base all its internal APIs on UTF-16.
I assume you're referring to the internal representation of strings. Describing it as "UTF-32 with space-saving optimizations" is missing the point, and also a contradiction in terms. Yes, it is a system that uses the same number of bytes per character within a given string (and chooses that width according to the string contents). This makes random access possible. Doing anything else would have broken historical expectations about string slicing. There are good arguments that one shouldn't write code like that anyway, but it's hard to identify anything "sub-optimal" about the result except that strings like "I'm learning 日本語" use more memory than they might be able to get away with. (But there are other strings, like "ℍℯℓ℗", that can use a 2-byte width while the UTF-8 encoding would add 3 bytes per character.)
> Python essentially bet on UTF-32 (with space-saving optimisations)
How so? Python3 strings are unicode and all the encoding/decoding functions default to utf-8. In practice this means all the python I write is utf-8 compatible unicode and I don't ever have to think about it.