logoalt Hacker News

The pleasures of poor product design

111 pointsby NaOHtoday at 1:00 AM35 commentsview on HN

Comments

ChrisMarshallNYtoday at 2:56 AM

I’ve always enjoyed the “useless teapot” that Don Norman has on the cover of DOET: https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/61KtiLw7BtL...

show 2 replies
userbinatortoday at 3:47 AM

IC: With AI getting bigger and more controversial and so on, have you used AI to create any of these designs?

That is an interesting point to bring up, because this type of "almost but not quite right" is exactly what AI seems to naturally create.

show 1 reply
Noe2097today at 7:05 AM

"what if objects were actually designed for a bad user experience, instead of a good one? she recalled in a 2018 TED talk. That was my ‘eureka’ moment."

Or, she stumbled upon some article or the very Wikipedia page about it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chind%C5%8Dgu

AriedKtoday at 6:57 AM

This gets quite close to chindogu, the Japanese art of designing objects that kind of serve a very niche purpose, but then without being useful. https://www.tofugu.com/japan/chindogu-japanese-inventions/

bcherrytoday at 2:22 AM

this really reminds me of the "worst volume control" from reddit https://uxdesign.cc/the-worst-volume-control-ui-in-the-world...

Gigachadtoday at 3:24 AM

I love that these are all fairly beautiful, stuff you'd really love to have if it wasn't fundamentally unusable.

Incipienttoday at 7:25 AM

I feel like I've seen some of these designs a VERY long time ago? Is this something old that the person was just interviewed on recently?

show 3 replies
lelanthrantoday at 6:31 AM

This is a link to the interview. here is a link to the products website: https://www.theuncomfortable.com/#

whiteboardrtoday at 5:44 AM

It's missing the Magic Mouse.

anonymous344today at 4:59 AM

as a designer and innovator, i appriciete this. this gives me ideas really out of box, just to see these. amazing!

i also do this for ui and app logic: go to some Microslop service, they are all like these...sad but true

jrmgtoday at 2:42 AM

Now I’m wondering how you could create ‘uncomfortable’ versions of simple command line tools (ls, cat, more etc.) or perhaps shells.

Emacs and/or vi, depending on your inclination, have text editors covered already, of course ;-)

show 4 replies
camillomillertoday at 8:07 AM

The glasses would be great for pool playing, as they would sit higher on your line of sight :)

eszedtoday at 3:30 AM

What's wrong about the glasses? I've been staring at them and trying to figure out why they're unworkable, as opposed to just a quirky pair of specs.

show 5 replies
imp0cattoday at 7:19 AM

The funny thing is that the toothbrush would actually come in handy for cleaning stuff other than teeth.

For example, the inner water tank of a robotic vacuum.

rajesh_me291091today at 9:22 AM

[dead]

keithnztoday at 2:15 AM

given the title, so may software developers must be living in bliss! /s

abstractspoontoday at 7:24 AM

All seems very contrived. Not what I would call creative