logoalt Hacker News

Rapzidtoday at 3:04 AM2 repliesview on HN

I use GitHub Copilot and unfortunately there has been a weird regression in the bundled Plan mode. It suddenly, when they added the new plan memory, started getting both VERY verbose in the plan output and also vague in the details. It's adding a lot of step that are like "design" and "figure out" and railroads you into implementation without asking follow-up questions.


Replies

NSPG911today at 7:39 AM

> VERY verbose in the plan output

Is that an issue? GitHub charges per-request, not per-token, so a verbose output and short output will be the same cost

What model are you using?

whalesaladtoday at 4:13 AM

I find that even with opus 4.6, copilot feels like it’s handicapped. I’m not sure if it’s related to memory or what but if I give two tasks to opus4.6 one in CC and one in Copilot, CC is substantially better.

I’ve been really enjoying Codex CLI recently though. It seems to do just as well as Opus 4.6, but using the standard GPT 5.4

show 1 reply