logoalt Hacker News

lmmtoday at 5:12 AM0 repliesview on HN

> Why do you care how much effort it took the engineer to make it?

Because they're implicitly asking me to put in effort as a reviewer. Pretending that they put more effort in than they have is extremely rude, and intentionally or not, generating a large volume of code amounts to misleading your potential reviewers.

> If there was a huge amount of tedium that they used Claude Code for, then reviewed and cleaned up so that it’s indistinguishable from whatever you’d expect from a human; what’s it to you?

They never do though. These kind of imaginary good AI-based workflows are a "real communism has never been tried" thing.

> If your project is gaining useful functionality, that seems like a win.

Lines of code impose a maintenance cost, and that goes triple when the code quality is low (as is always the case for actually existing AI-generated code). The cost is probably higher than the benefit.