logoalt Hacker News

lesuoractoday at 11:26 AM1 replyview on HN

We do throw out everything from physics 101.

The movement of satellites is not modeled using distance = speed * time. It would do well to consider if econ 101 is an accurate way to model the world since for other domains the 101 course is not.


Replies

pembrooktoday at 12:08 PM

Yet the overwhelming factor in modeling the movement of those satellites is still distance = speed * time.

The existence of nuance and external factors don't negate the original principle.

The equivalent to arguments made by 'economics deniers' in this thread would be if you argued: the satellite moving at 7.8 km/s actually causes the earth to spin 8 km/s faster, so trying to make the satellite move faster makes it go slower! Applying acceleration doesn't help!

No. Making the satellite move faster generally makes it move faster. Building more housing generally makes it cheaper.

Let's not do the HN thing and get lost in pedantry.

show 1 reply