logoalt Hacker News

incognito124last Thursday at 1:32 PM7 repliesview on HN

Possibly the worst possible news for the Python ecosystem. Absolutely devastating. Congrats to the team


Replies

dcrelast Thursday at 3:50 PM

Can't blame you for not trusting OpenAI, but it seems to me they would gain very little from fucking up uv (or more precisely doing things that have a side effect of fucking up uv), and they have tons of incentive to cultivate developer good will. Better to think of buying and supporting a project like this as a very cheap way to make developers think they're not so bad.

show 2 replies
antodlast Thursday at 6:20 PM

One thing to keep in mind is that uv was the product of a whole lot of packaging PEPs finally landing and standards being set. That combined with not having to support all the old baggage meant they could have an effect modernizing community packaging standards.

I hope those two factors mean that if things go really wrong, then the clean(ish) break with all the non standard complex legacy means an easier future for community packaging efforts.

show 1 reply
blitzarlast Thursday at 2:24 PM

I hope they got paid, I will be very sad if they didn't at least get G5 money.

show 1 reply
vdfslast Thursday at 2:22 PM

On the other hand, we get to see what other thing will try to replace pip

show 1 reply
PurpleRamenlast Thursday at 2:31 PM

Yeah, no. there are many worse news than this.

In the worst case, Astral will stop developing their tools, someone else will pick them up and will continue polishing them. In the best case, they will just continue as they did until now, and nothing will really change on that front.

Astral is doing good work, but their greatest benefit for the ecosystem so far was showing what's possible and how it's down. Now everyone can take up the quest from here and continue. So any possible harm from here out will be not that deep, at worst we will be missing out on many more cool things they could have built.

nacozarinalast Thursday at 11:51 PM

as a long-time python-hater, i am jack’s smug smiling face

nsbklast Thursday at 6:34 PM

Let the forks roll!