logoalt Hacker News

islandfox100last Thursday at 2:55 PM2 repliesview on HN

Maybe I'm reading wrong here, but what's the implication of the clean room re-implementations? Someone else is cloning with a changed license, but if I'm still on the GPL licensed tool, how am I "not protected"?


Replies

darkwaterlast Thursday at 3:22 PM

1. Company A develops Project One as GPLv3

2. BigCo bus Company A

3a. usually here BigCo should continue to develop Project One as GPLv3, or stop working on it and the community would fork and it and continue working on it as GPLv3

3b. BigCo does a "clean-room" reimplementation of Project One and releases it under proprietary licence. Community can still fork the older version and work on it, but BigCo can continue to develop and sell their "original" version.

show 2 replies
erulast Thursday at 2:58 PM

There's basically no different between GPL and BSD in that case.