logoalt Hacker News

OsrsNeedsf2Ptoday at 5:39 PM5 repliesview on HN

4chan's lawyer's response:

"In the only country in which 4chan operates, the United States, it is breaking no law and indeed its conduct is expressly protected by the First Amendment."[0]

[0] https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c624330lg1ko


Replies

deaddodotoday at 6:21 PM

As shown in that same article, they also responded:

>>>

"Companies – wherever they're based – are not allowed to sell unsafe toys to children in the UK. And society has long protected youngsters from things like alcohol, smoking and gambling. The digital world should be no different," she said.

"The UK is setting new standards for online safety. Age checks and risk assessments are cornerstones of our laws, and we'll take robust enforcement action against firms that fall short."

<<<

Quite frankly she seems completely out of touch with her own argument. The UK can certainly legislate away tobacco sales, for instance; they can't go after tobacco producers in a foreign state. 4Chan operates in the US and is a US company. They have no jurisdiction over it, even if their citizenry can access it; it's on them to block that access if they don't like it. Unless they're also implying that the US government should be allowed to go after UK companies that don't follow it's free speech regulations because American citizens can access them.

show 6 replies
dmixtoday at 7:02 PM

The lawyer is great on Twitter, he's not only defending 4chan, he's on a crusade to prevent this stuff in the future and trying to get bills passed in the US.

https://x.com/prestonjbyrne

kpstoday at 6:35 PM

It's unfortunate that the US lawyers did not cite the reply given in Arkell v Pressdram.

show 1 reply
petcattoday at 6:20 PM

And now we'll watch the UK take the logical next step which is for the government to mandate that all ISPs in the country block 4chan.

CCP "Great Firewall" style.

show 4 replies
Onavotoday at 6:40 PM

The directors and officers better not transit through Heathrow without giving the current whitehouse admin a hefty donation first.

Mother Britain will be happy to make an example out of them if Uncle Sam doesn't intervene.