logoalt Hacker News

designerarvidyesterday at 6:09 PM3 repliesview on HN

Reproducing someone’s intellectual property and publishing it is exactly what constitutes a copyright violation.

You can retype someone’s book with your keyboard, it’s still not yours.


Replies

Sharlinyesterday at 6:21 PM

Reproducing the surface behavior of a program, no matter how faithfully, is not in itself copyright violation if it's a cleanroom implementation. But int this case it's not to write the new one, the developers studied (and manually translated to C++) the original code, not just the program's behavior. So this is more of a case of a derived work, like a translation of a novel.

anthkyesterday at 6:49 PM

Learn something new, dear GenZers:

https://osgameclones.com/

Maybe you all realize how much brainwashed from corporations yall actually are.

show 2 replies
orpheayesterday at 6:26 PM

Reproducing is absolutely not a copyright violation. Otherwise emulators would have no legal option to exist.

show 2 replies