logoalt Hacker News

peacebeardyesterday at 10:25 PM1 replyview on HN

In my experience trying to push the onus of filtering out slop onto reviewers is both ineffective and unfair to the reviewer. When you submit code for review you are saying "I believe to the best of my ability that this code is high quality and adequate but it's best to have another person verify that." If the AI has done things without you noticing, you haven't reviewed its output well enough yet and shouldn't be submitting it to another person yet.


Replies

skydhashyesterday at 11:56 PM

Code review should be a transmission of ideas and helping spotting errors that can slip in due to excessive familiarity with the changes (which are often glaring to anyone other than the author).

If you're not familiar with the patch enough to answer any question about it, you shouldn't submit it for review.